O'Reilly's Pub

Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Columbus’ North High Street, O'Reilly's Pub offers an authentic pub experience that combines hearty, flavorful cuisine with a warm, inviting atmosphere. This family-owned gem feels like a cozy neighborhood retreat, where every visit is greeted with familiar faces and genuine hospitality.

O'Reilly's boasts an impressive menu that caters to lovers of classic American pub fare with a delicious twist. Their burgers are a standout, drawing raves for juicy, expertly seasoned patties like the iconic Pepper Burger, the indulgent Chili Cheese Burger, and the savory Duff Patty Melt. For a satisfying sandwich fix, the Johnny’s Sub with a Bacon Burger is a delightful crowd-pleaser, especially when paired with crispy, seasoned sweet potato fries. The menu also offers perfectly fried Chicken Tenders, loaded Nachos, and shareable appetizers such as Fried Mushrooms and gooey Cheese Sticks, including the extra-bacon variety that adds an irresistible smoky crunch.

For those craving comfort food beyond the typical pub offerings, the hearty Beef Stroganoff over Noodles is a rich, flavorful choice that feels like a warm embrace on a cooler evening. And don’t miss out on decadent desserts—creamy, fudgy Chocolate Brownies make for a perfect finale after a satisfying meal.

Beverage options here keep pace with the menu’s quality, featuring classics like cold Guinness and inventive cocktails such as the crisp Titos and Tonic. Seasonal touches, like the St. Patrick’s Day specials including the refreshing Green Tea or the unique Breast Shot, showcase O’Reilly’s lively spirit and connection to community traditions.

O'Reilly's atmosphere is the kind of cozy, divey charm that makes it a beloved local haunt. As one regular puts it, it channels a small-town vibe right in the heart of Columbus, with friendly staff who quickly become familiar, personalized touchstones during your visit. The festive décor and a welcoming environment create a perfect setting for both casual dinners and spirited nights out.

Customer reviews reflect the care and quality that define O'Reilly's Pub. Trung Phan calls it a “solid burger place,” praising their juicy offerings and recommending fries over chips to elevate your meal. Clear Water Prowash highlights the attentive service and spotless facilities, noting that everything from the burgers to the wings hits the mark. Leighton Jones appreciates the attentive staff and the perfectly executed fish and chips, while Alexander “Codie” West shares a heartfelt endorsement: a true favorite spot for drinks and fun, emphasizing the warmth of the staff and the inviting small-town feel. Lastly, Mark Kremer describes O'Reilly’s as a “comfortable place” infused with festive charm, evoking the feel of a classic, cozy bar experience.

Whether you’re stopping by for succulent burgers, a crisp pint, or just a spot to unwind with friends, O'Reilly's Pub brings an authentic, welcoming essence to Columbus’ dining scene that keeps locals coming back time and again.

Contact: 2822 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202 | Phone: +1 614-262-6343